Skip to main content

Why We Love Football. Joe Posnanski.

 


Why We Love Football.   A history in 100 Moments.      Joe Posnanski. 

There is no question American’s love their lists from best movies, songs, gadgets and even football plays.    Esteemed author Joe Posnanski, who has tried his luck at putting together a list of “greatest” moments in American football history, writes in his latest book Why We Love Football.  This is a much anticipated follow up to his popular book Why We Love Baseball   but only a history of 50 moments.  However, unlike the baseball themed manuscript which selected moments based on a semi-complicated formula consisting of importance, distinctiveness, emotion and awesomeness, the author explains early on that the football edition of historical moments was based just on emotion. 

One of the most gripping sections of the book appears near the end.  In fact, this play happened in a 1972 NFL playoff game between the Raiders and the Steelers in Pittsburgh and was ranked the #3 moment.   (Posnanski admits or acknowledges that this could have easily been placed at #1) The author impressively broke down the reception in 100 steps within itself and done in a way that was easy to follow and gripping at the same time.  This, of course, was just one of many intriguing stories.   The book features moments from not only professional and college football but high school and semi-pro plays as well.    Furthermore, the book does not suffer from recency bias as some of the reported moments happened in the early days of football featuring topics centered around the galloping ghost, George “Papa” Halas and the Chicago Bears, and coaching legend Paul Brown.    

What is more is that the book features many additional upsides.    One example is that while the moments are ranked from 100 to 1 in the author’s order, the reader is told early on that the book comes with no instructions.  The reader is free to pick and choose whichever chapter they like in any order they choose since there is not a distinctive connection between each selected moment. The chapters are short and easy to finish.   An unexpected bonus are the numerous footnotes included within the pages of each story.     Podnansky inserts little tidbits about the topics ranging from humorous to fascinating to personal connection.    In fact, one of his footnotes tells the football fan to look carefully at the stories ending with 0.   Those stories are “secretly” woven into another countdown of sorts.   That is, the author’s version of the 10 greatest players in pro football history including the likes of Aaron Donald, Walter Payton, Jim Brown and Jerry Rice among others. 

A small downside to any book of lists, particularly a lengthy one that contains one hundred stories and dozens of additional tidbits, is that it may be hard for the reader to retain or remember all the stories.    While the moments range from various football topics, the moments can blend particularly depending on how the reader processes and schedules their way through this opus.     

Now did Podnanski select the very best one hundred moments in football over the last one hundred years or so?   Quite possibly, yes, but the reader will have to decide for themselves since this is a monumental, subjective task.  While there have been countless plays and moments in football history, most fans would have a hard time coming up with identifying that many plays let alone some of the greatest since the inception of the sport.  For this reason alone, it is why football fans, but sports fans, too, will glean more than they expected from the three hundred and seventy pages.   While the list is quite subjective and up for debate the quality of the way the stories are delivered is a fun, often hilarious, way to unfold historical, emotional moments in America’s most favorite spectator game.           

You might like to read this book if you are a college football fan.

You might like to read this book if you are a fan of professional football.

You might like to read this book if you are a football fan.

You might like to read this book if you are a sports fan.

You might like to read this book if you relish reading lists of historical moments. 

Learn more about the author on X:  https://x.com/JPosnanski


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The 1976 National Champion Pitt Panthers. David Finoli.

  The 1976 National Champion Pitt Panthers.     David Finoli. Miracle on Cardiac Hill.      It is not often that fans get to see their favorite college football team win a championship.    It is even more extraordinary when that happens during the first year of ever attending games for your favorite college football team.     Well, that was exactly my experience in the fall of 1976, as a 9-year-old, when I was afforded the great luxury and opportunity with my family to attend University of Pittsburgh football games that season for the first time.      It was a historical season for many reasons but also an exciting time for sports in western Pennsylvania as the Pittsburgh Steelers were winning super bowls and the Pittsburgh Pirates were regular contenders for the National League pennant.     Author David Finoli explains how the local University captured some of that Esprit De corps in hi...
1 comment
Read more

Uninvited: The 1963 Pitt Panthers. David Finoli & Gary Kinn.

It seems hard to believe that a team with only one loss could be left out of a post season in any sport.     However, that is exactly what happened to the University of Pittsburgh’s football team upon the completion of the 1963 season.      Pittsburgh writer and sports authority David Finoli and his co-author Gary Kinn wrote about this underrated team and their surprising success through what was not only challenge in western PA but also took place during a turbulent time throughout the nation.     Finoli and Kinn go through each game of the season explaining the important details of each contest, even including the box score and statistics.     We like that they provided key plays but did not overwork the explanation in each chapter.     The authors mostly kept to the facts at hand without offering personal opinions about the quality of play and performance.    Instead, they let the quotes from ...
1 comment
Read more

Iron in the Blood. Jay Busbee.

   Iron in the Blood.    Jay Busbee. How the Alabama vs. Auburn Rivalry Shaped the Soul of the South.    As far as college football rivalries go the annual game between the two biggest schools in the state of Alabama ranks among the best in the nation.     The game, played at the end of the regular season, is known as the Iron Bowl because it traditionally took place in Birmingham, the state’s largest city.    However, the Pittsburgh in the south, happened to be fertile region blessed with iron-ore resources at one point during the 20th century, hence the moniker that sticks to this day.    Veteran author Jay Busbee decided to add another literary resource, for which there is seemingly no shortage of documentation, describing this rivalry and fascinating topic by publishing his book Iron in the Blood .    This is a book that gives equal quarters to both of the prominent state schools and fervently discusses...
1 comment
Read more